Legal education in Bangladesh has been facing a pity condition. Though we are producing a huge number of law graduates every year, however, majority of them are having under-qualified or non-qualified in terms of their legal knowledge, research, analytical, and presentation skills and competitiveness in a globalized legal profession.
The frustrating situation has been [is] better described as a “disastrous situation” by none other than the Chairman of the National Human Rights Commission and a renowned Law Professor Dr. Mizanur Rahman in a recent interview with me.
This downwards trend in legal education have been contributed by the obsolete and archical curriculum, traditional teaching and examination methods, lack of practical and clinical aspects in the curriculum, huge gap in relations between teachers and students, teachers' engagement in out-side activities (other than own institutions), lack of interest, motivation, opportunity and skills for research and publications.
The scenario of legal research is at pity stage as well. A handful of law schools at public and private universities offer courses on legal research and writing. However, those also lack of standard and quality due to lack of resources (i.e., library materials, Internet faculties etc), skills and expertise of the respective faculty members. The private law colleges which are producing the majority of law graduates don't offer similar courses. That is why a great number of lawyers (and future judges) are coming from there with out skills in legal research and writing. These skills are taught at law schools even in countries like India and Nepal as well.
Our faculty members are coming back with education and degrees in the developed countries, however, they are not taking any initiative to introduce best practices out of their knowledge and learning.
The journals published by law schools at public universities (not regular in publication) do follow a principle of “limiting knowledge.” For example, the Journal of the Faculty of Law at the University of Dhaka accepts articles only from their respective faculty members. This is also true for other public universities which hardly happens in the universities in other countries.
When a journal is supposed to explore and disseminate new knowledge on a given subject, how come it will probe its standard while there is no competitiveness in selecting and reviewing articles independently. Who will give a guaranty that only teachers could write “best articles”? This so-called journals are also not publicly available as I experienced.
Given my recent affiliation for a year [as] a Hubert H. Humphrey Fellow at the University of Minnesota Law School and Human Rights Center in Minneapolis, U.S.A., I found that three of their journals are being edited and published by only students (appointed by the schools on a rotation basis) alongside two others by faculty members, and two more by jointly by faculties and students. Those are coming out on a scheduled dates over the years incorporating articles selected on its originality, analysis, quality and contribution. They hardly bother about whether the author is a teacher or students, or a practicing lawyer. The same I found at the West Bengal National University of Juridical Sciences in Kolkata, India.
Here, our professional, research and training institutions are also lacking in terms of quality research and publications. The Bangladesh Bar Council and Law Commission neither have research and publication projects nor journals. The Bangladesh Institute of Law and International Affairs (BILIA) had its last issue of the biannual publication, Bangladesh Journal of Law in 2007. Though the Judicial Administration and Training Institute (JATI) has its own journal however, its lacks professionalism and quality in publishing a research journal.
Dr. Uttam Kumar Das
LL.M. (Minn., U.S.A.), Ph.D.
Advocate, Supreme Court of Bangladesh
*Originally appeared in The Daily Star, "Law & Our Rights" Section, 12 November 2010; link: http://www.thedailystar.net/law/2010/11/02/letter.htm
No comments:
Post a Comment